If You’re Concerned About Privacy, Don’t Get a Smartphone

If You’re Concerned About Privacy, Don’t Get a Smartphone

Personal privacy is dead. Yes, the NSA, FBI, DOJ, and every other government acronym is reading your messages and tracking your movements. The concept sounds like a conspiracy theorist’s wet dream, but truth is in the recent revelations. Google, with its massive data centers, algorithms, and supercomputers, knows more about you than probably any company on the planet – except maybe Facebook.

Spy vs Spy

Many people purchase new phones only to get frustrated by the overabundance of pre-installed software: crapware. Recently, a reader contacted me about this issue:

I recently purchased the Samsung Galaxy S3 and I noticed that there are Google programs that are pre-installed on the device. These applications are able to access all of my information and this really bothers me. I called Samsung and their response was they are sorry but the programs cannot be removed and they cannot refund me for my purchase. Whether I use these programs or not they can control everything. It is a good phone and works well but I did not agree to give my information to anyone who wants it. Please give me information on whether there is anything I can do about this matter. I have no interest in keeping a device that is infringing on my privacy and I want everyone else to know that there is a very large problem at hand.

I get a lot of similar emails, which usually end up getting a short response such as, tough.

This issue of pre-installed software isn’t anything new, nor is the fact that “Google’s programs . . . are able to access [a lot] of information,” but I think I need to dispel a few myths:

First, Google’s programs cannot control your device. Most of the Google-built apps do not come pre-loaded on any device. Rather, you’ll have to download them from Google Play or some other Android store. Any pre-installed apps are permissions-based apps for services. There is a Google Settings app, which controls sync between Google+ and Android.

Second, no app will control your phone. Apps control services, not they system. Further, Android is developed in such a way as to only allow the apps to access particular Android system services (e.g., GPS, phone calls, SMS) and not the entire device. Android calls these access allowances, permissionsThe apps must ask for certain access permissions, and you must grant those by clicking “OK” or “install.”

Third, you use your Google account (Gmail) to create a sync between your device and Google. The Google account controls the transfer between the information contained on your device and Google’s cloud. You can bypass the Google account setup by clicking “Skip” on the setup screen.

Fourth, no matter what you do, “they” know. Search Google for cell phone triangulation where you’ll find an array of good, bad, and ugly. Cell phone triangulation has been around along time, and it’s used quite often to catch someone.

Finally, as spy novel enthusiasts know, the only way to be certain about limited government intrusions is to disconnect altogether – no email, no phone, and meet in public parks and coffee shops. Recently, a federal judge in New York ruled (ACLU story) that cell phones users do not have a reasonable expectation of privacy unless they turn off their cell phones. I believe we’ll see a lot more of these types of rulings.

If you’re really, really, really concerned about your privacy invasion, you can do a couple things:

  1. Get rid of all electronic devices and abandon accounts. See my “finally” note above.
  2. Turn off “geolocation” on your phone: Settings > Location > uncheck all boxes under Location ON Settings. 
  3. Check app permissions before installing any applications
  4. Deal with reputable developers, carriers, and manufacturers
  5. Check out EFF’s Surveillance Self-Defense Project
  6. Remove the battery from your device except to make phone calls
  7. Abandon your Google account (see number 1 above)
  8. Disable your phone’s bloatware
  9. Accept the “new” reality

Thanks for the questions, but, as you see, I’m not so sympathetic when someone shoots off their alarmist view of cell phone privacy. With the convenience of a computer in your pocket, you’re also delivering (relinquishing) some privacy to the cell phone carriers, app developers, and ultimately, the government. Don’t forget the Arabian proverb about the camel in the tent.

Weekly News Round-up: What You May Have Missed in the World of Android

Weekly News Round-up: What You May Have Missed in the World of Android

Fantastic or exciting. That’s how I describe the Google I/O 2013 events I viewed. I wrote about my excitement with Google’s upgraded features. Yesterday, I got my invite to join the new Google Maps. Now I really wish that I had Chromebook Pixel because the maps would look great using a touch experience to navigate. GoogleContinue Reading

The New Stuff from Google Lawyers Will Care About

The New Stuff from Google Lawyers Will Care About

Google I/O 2013 continues, but yesterday was the big keynote speech highlighting changes to some of Google’s programs and services. While some rumors came true – there was a “new” phone announced, just not the X Phone – others did not – no Android 4.3. Some view I/O 2013 as Google’s act of cleaning upContinue Reading

Google I/O 2013 Live Blog

Google I/O 2013 Live Blog

Here’s my simple contribution to the Google I/O 2013 conference:Continue Reading

What I’m Watching at Google I/O 2013

What I’m Watching at Google I/O 2013

In about 6 hours from now, Google will officially open I/O 2013. This is a Google geek’s Mecca, where Google’s team of developers and honchos announce new products, consult on product development, and show just how cool Google really is. Google I/O isn’t for the faint hearted. It’s an incredibly boring CLE-like experience designed withContinue Reading

New Google Play Store Released Ahead of Google I/O 2013

New Google Play Store Released Ahead of Google I/O 2013

Today marks the beginning of Google I/O 2013. In preparation for I/O 2013, Google also released a new Play Store. The update is expected to add enhanced interfaces for Google Play’s newest feature: Google Play Games. Games will feature multiplayer action and cloud saves, among other additions. The Google Play Store build update is 4.1.6,Continue Reading

Catch Me on Legal Talk Network

Catch Me on Legal Talk Network

Last week I had the opportunity to join Jim Calloway and Sharon Nelson for their most recent episode of The Digital Edge. Sharon and Jim’s show is actually one of the few podcasts I listen to on a regular basis. The episode runs 26 minutes. You can visit the podcast page, or download the episode here. Note,Continue Reading

Happy Mother’s Day

Happy Mother’s Day

Hopefully you’re starting this beautiful celebration of women with sunshine, twirping birds, and happiness. So, to those mothers, and especially Mrs. The Droid Lawyer and my own mom. This video recognizes their work, sacrifice, and tolerance: Oh, and you’ll also want to check out the Google Doodle for today:   Happy Mother’s Day!Continue Reading

Weekly News Round-up: What You May Have Missed in the World of Android

Weekly News Round-up: What You May Have Missed in the World of Android

T-minus 5 days. That’s how long we have to wait until Google I/O 2013. If you’re not that excited about the event, don’t worry, you’re in the vast majority. If you are excited, or just curious, I/O 2013 looks fun. Bad news though, if you don’t have tickets, you’re stuck out of luck. Never fear,Continue Reading

12 Apps Always on my Android Device

12 Apps Always on my Android Device

Yesterday, I posted five ways you’re not making the most of your Android device. My posts on some useful apps for lawyers, this one on 5 unknown apps I can’t live without, and my 5 must have apps, are popular landing spots. Now, I want to give you the 12 apps I immediately install on my phone or tablet. This listContinue Reading